The Teams[Home]
[Great Games]
[All images are clickable]
[Principal sources: 'The West Australian' of 4 August, 6 August and 8 August 1910]
"I have no hesitation in naming this Port Adelaide team as the best club 18 that has visited W.A., and I am not forgetting Collingwood's two visits, nor those of Essendon, Fitzroy and St Kilda. They were the team they looked." (Dolph Heinrichs, East Fremantle club historian, writing just after World War Two)
Related Link: SAFL Match Programme And Results Season 1910 (PDF)
Game One: East Fremantle vs. Port Adelaide
Game Two: WAFL vs. Port Adelaide
League footballers during the early years of the twentieth century were not well paid, if indeed they were paid at all, but that does not mean that involvement in football at its highest level was devoid of perks. Of these, perhaps the most prized was the opportunity to travel interstate, and to see at first hand parts of Australia that might otherwise remain forever inaccessible. In 1910, for example, at least ten league clubs from the three main football states embarked on interstate or country tours involving a combination of sight-seeing and challenge matches (see footnote 1).
|
Port Adelaide, which by the end of the 1910 season would be able to proclaim itself both premiers of the state, and champions of Australia, commenced its tour of Western Australia with a visit to the Kalgoorlie/Boulder region, a bona fide hotbed of football which provided fifty per cent of the players for the state's 1908 and 1911 carnival teams. There can be little doubt that Port were well aware of the high quality of goldfields football, but for some reason they elected to field a team that was some way below full strength for their match with a GFL combination. Nevertheless, the two sides produced a wonderful exhibition of football, widely regarded as the finest seen on the goldfields up to that point, with the GFL side scoring a superb and wholly meritorious 17 point victory, 12.12 (84) to 9.13 (67). As far as Port were concerned, however, it was the games on the coast that really mattered. In 1909, East Fremantle had visited Adelaide as part of an eastern states tour, and, on the Jubilee Oval, consigned the Magpies to an embarrassing 21 point defeat, a result which everyone connected with Port was anxious to avenge. They would get the chance to do so in the first of two matches to be played during the coastal phase of their trip. |
Chas Doig |
Not that this would be easy, for Old Easts were themselves a formidable combination who, in 1910, would secure their eighth premiership in eleven seasons. Smaller and lighter in the main than Port, they were arguably pacier, and their undoubted all-round football talent was amplified by finely honed aggression and excellent teamwork.
The second coastal match would provide Port with an opportunity to serve as ambassadors for the entire state of South Australia, for it would see the Magpies facing a combination comprised of players from all eight WAFL clubs - in other words, a virtual state team. This was clearly the pinnacle of the trip, and the only match in which Port elected to field a full strength side. It was a match which lived up to expectations in every sense, but the fact that it was not played in Victoria and did not involve VFL clubs has meant that it has been almost completely forgotten.
Game One: East Fremantle vs. Port Adelaide, Wednesday 3 August 1910
“......it is safe to say that such high marking and so much of it have not been seen here for many a day. When Harvey Kelly, Dolph Heinrichs and Goddard were playing on the coast football enthusiasts were treated to something of the same kind of thing, but we never had six or eight of those champions in the one team as the Ports have now.” ('The West Australian', Saturday 6 August 1910)
The match took place at the WACA ground, in splendid, dry weather, with experienced umpire Ivo Crapp in charge. The attendance was undoubtedly adversely affected by a tram strike, but was nevertheless quite satisfactory for a Wednesday afternoon game, and raised receipts of £80. Heavy overnight rain had left the cricket wicket area somewhat slippery, but the rest of the playing surface was dry and firm.
Old Easts were minus only Dave Christy from what might be adjudged their first choice eighteen, while Port were without just two key players in 'Shine' Hosking and Horrie Pope.
EAST FREMANTLE: Beswick, Bailey, S.Doig, Jas Doig (captain), Chas Doig, Clive Doig, Craig, Sharpe, Parsons, Spence, N.Wrightson, C.Wrightson, Corkhill, Curran, Riley, Robinson, Sweetman, Strang
PORT ADELAIDE: Callinan, Curnow, Cavanagh, Congear, Dewar, Dempster, Mason, Manson, Magor, McEwen, McFarlane, Mack, Oliver, Middleton, Rose, Woollard (captain), Hansen, Stidston
|
Jack Mack |
"The visitors were a fine, strapping set of athletes with height, weight and reach to back up a thorough knowledge of football." They played a hard, physical game involving prolific use of handball, and aerially they were much superior to the locals. When the ball was on the ground, however, Old Easts displayed superior pace and considerable cleverness, factors which more or less compensated for Port's supremacy in other areas. The opening term provided a see-saw struggle, with the ball moving rapidly from one end of the ground to the other. On balance, the home side probably enjoyed slightly more of the play, both territorially and in terms of possession, but when the quarter time bell rang there was nothing separating the teams on the scoreboard. Quarter Time: East Fremantle 2.1 (13); Port Adelaide 2.1 (13) |
|
The second quarter was a vastly different affair, with the visitors dominating all over the ground - "as one spectator observed, it wasn't a match at all, it was a procession, in which the local men took the part of onlookers". With Port's players, on average, almost a stone heavier than their opponents, some members of the Old Easts team were made to look like schoolboys. Only twice during the term did the blue and whites manage to convey the ball into their attacking zone, and both times "it was returned with a rapidity that was electrifying". Whereas Port handled the ball smoothly and with great assurance, the Old Easts players often seemed overwhelmed by the sheer physicality of the opposition, and were prone to much fumbling and hesitancy. Nevertheless, they defended with a certain degree of conviction and no small amount of skill, and the Magpies' tally of 2.5 for the quarter was scant reward for their superiority. As the home side's skipper Jas Doig would no doubt have emphasised to his players in the changing rooms during the half time interval, the game was far from over. Half Time: Port Adelaide 4.6 (30); East Fremantle 2.1 (13) |
Sydney Parsons |
If Port's dominance during the second term had perhaps led many onlookers to assume that the match was over bar the shouting, the ferocity and passion with which Old Easts hurled themselves into the fray during the third quarter made it clear that this was very far from being the case. Although the visitors continued to exhibit football of the highest order, they did so only intermittently; in between, they had their hands full trying to contain an exuberant and extremely pacy local combination who were as buoyant and cocksure in this term as they had been tentative and cowed in the previous. By kicking 2.3 to 1.2 in this quarter Old Easts left the game beautifully poised at the final change. Three Quarter Time: Port Adelaide 5.8 (38); East Fremantle 4.4 (28)
| The final term provided spectators with some of the finest football seen in Perth for many years, with both sides contributing to the spectacle. Old Easts were out of the blocks faster, and for the first fifteen minutes of the quarter were much the better team. Port, however, showed just as much skill defending as they had demonstrated earlier in attack, and with ten minutes remaining all the blue and whites had managed to add to their score was a single goal, leaving them still 5 points adrift. Old Easts continued to press forward, however, and when Riley marked well within range of goal it elicited the noisiest response of the afternoon from the sparse but enthusiastic crowd. After prudently selecting a dry patch of turf, Riley placed the ball, carefully measured his run up, and focused his eyes on the two central uprights. The crowd held its collective breath as he trotted up to the ball - then groaned with disbelief as he failed to connect properly and sent the ball straight into the waiting arms of a Port Adelaide defender. The Magpies gratefully spirited the ball away, and minutes later posted their sixth, and match-sealing, goal. The final few minutes were dominated by the visitors, and when the bell rang the scoreboard showed Port Adelaide 6.10 (46); East Fremantle 5.4 (34). |
Dick Sweetman |
| 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | Pts | |
| Port Adelaide | 2.1 | 4.6 | 5.8 | 6.10 | 46 |
| East Fremantle | 2.1 | 2.1 | 4.4 | 5.4 | 34 |
BEST
- Port Adelaide:
GOALS - Port Adelaide: Hansen, Woollard 2; Callinan, Cavanagh East Fremantle: Chas Doig 2; Bailey, Robinson, Sweetman
Game Two: WAFL vs. Port Adelaide, Saturday 6 August 1910
“The
local combination is by no means, on paper at any rate, as strong as it could be
made, but, on the other hand, it must be remembered that the opposing side
represents only one South Australian club, and it is a big thing to pit it
against an eighteen picked from eight strong clubs in Western Australia.
Nevertheless, the Ports are a stalwart lot of footballers, and in their
match against the old Easts on the WACA ground last Wednesday, they gave an
exhibition of that strong, vigorous, telling play that marks them as champions.
There are some wonderful aerial explorers amongst them, and the beauty of
it is that they can all hold the ball and kick with some purpose.
They did not shine out in ground play on Wednesday, but the greasiness of
the arena may not have suited them so well as it did the light Easts.
Today they will be on a turf on which they can be absolutely sure of
their footing, no matter what the weather is like, and they should be able to
improve considerably upon the fine exhibition they gave three days ago.”
|
George Oakley |
The
match, played at Fremantle Oval, took place in sunny, dry, mild weather, with the playing surface in superb
condition. The attendance of
approximately 6,000 was a record for a match on the coast, as were the receipts
of £273 13s 6d (see footnote 2). The contest which
en As
intimated above, according
to the writer in ‘The West Australian’, the League combination was not the
strongest available, with at least five players arguably being included on the
basis of past reputations rather than current form.
However, “such men as strip for Port Adelaide at present might........
with confidence tackle the best team this state could put in the field”. The
Port Adelaide combination was stronger than that which had defeated |
Port
How The Teams Lined UpWAFL Combination kicking UP Port Adelaide kicking DOWN |
||||
| ******** | ||||
| G.Dempster | C.Cocks | T.McFarlane | ||
| H.Cordner (Perth - captain) | A.Robinson (East Fremantle) | H.Morgans (Subiaco) | ||
| F.Magor | H.Rose | E.Mason | ||
| H.Sharpe (East Fremantle) | D.Rogers (Perth) | C.McKenzie (East Perth) | ||
| H.Dewar | S.Hosking | W.Manson | ||
| S.Parsons (East Fremantle) | C.Waugh (Perth) | J.Jones (North Fremantle) | ||
| J.Woollard (captain) | H.Oliver | H.McEwen | ||
| G.Oakley (Subiaco) | G.Balme (West Perth) | A.Hesford (East Perth) | ||
| A.Congear | F.Hansen | J.Middleton | ||
| A.Spence (East Fremantle) | W.Crawford (East Perth) | J.Beswick (East Fremantle) | ||
| Followers | Rover | |||
| E.Callinan | F.Curnow | J.Mack | ||
| J.Hesketh (Midland Junction) | T.Willoughby (Perth) | W.Orr (Perth) | ||
Seven of the eight WAFL clubs had at least one player in the side, the somewhat surprising exception being South Fremantle. Not only were South one of the strongest teams in the competition in 1910, eventually finishing 4th, but the match was being played on their own home ground.
|
Jack Woollard |
The WAFL combination lined up in all blue, while the visitors were in their usual black and white striped jumpers, with black shorts, and black and white hooped hose. Play
in the opening term was “decidedly even” although “two capital shots”
from the Perth pair of Billy Orr and Dave Rogers helped the West secure a narrow quarter time
advantage, 2.3 (15) to 1.4 (10).
Port
The
second quarter saw the home side assume control, and produce some stunning
football, to open up a healthy 17 point advantage, 4.8 (32) to 1.9 (15).
For the only time in the match, Port’s players seemed slower than their
opponents, who were roared on with rapturous enthusiasm by the parochial, but by
no means unsporting, crowd. |
In the third quarter, just as they had during the second term against Old Easts, Port produced a concerted display of tremendous football to completely turn the tables on their opponents. Only in kicking for goal was there any noticeable deficiency. Time after time Oliver, at centre half forward, soared above the packs to take telling, one grab marks, and as the quarter went on his dominance began rubbing off on players like McEwen, Hansen and Congear, who hitherto had scarcely been sighted. Around the packs, Mack became just as hyperactive and effective as Orr had been for the west earlier. Seventeen points adrift as the quarter commenced, Port took just fourteen minutes to capture the lead, and had their kicking been straighter they might well have put the game out of the coastal combination’s reach. As it was, they added 4.7 for the term, while the westerners managed just two serious forward forays, which yielded a solitary point, so that at the final change the scoreboard showed the visitors on 5.16 (46) leading the home side 4.9 (33).
The
WAFL combination started the last quarter determinedly, and managed the first score, a
behind. Port, however, hit back in
sterling fashion, and soon had their sixth major on the board.
|
The
remainder of the term saw the West Australians dominate territorially, with Port
defending desperately, albeit with considerable skill.
Nevertheless, the Western Australian team gradually clawed their way back into the game,
and with five minutes left the scoreboard read Port Adelaide 6.17 (53); WAFL
6.10 (46).
A scrambled behind to the west soon followed which left them needing just
one straight kick to tie the match. With
three minutes to go, they were presented with a golden opportunity to do so, but
Harry Cordner, having marked well within range, and almost straight in front, somehow
conspired to kick the ball out on the full a good thirty yards wide of the posts.
The crowd groaned in disgust. How Cordner responded, or felt, is
unrecorded. Moments
later, the west added another scrambled behind, but the final two minutes saw Port
cleverly maintaining possession to run out 5 points winners, 6.17 (53) to 6.12
(48). |
Harold Oliver |
The
best player afield was Hosking, who “was opposed by Waugh, who has time and
again proved his worth in that portion of the field, and as evidence of the
wonderful dash and skill of the Port Adelaide man it may be mentioned that the
plucky and diminutive Perthite was completely outclassed on the day’s play.
Round about the centre it was Hosking first, last and all the time.”
| 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | Pts | |
| Port Adelaide | 1.4 | 1.9 | 5.16 | 6.17 | 53 |
| WAFL Combination | 2.3 | 4.8 | 4.9 | 6.12 | 48 |
BEST
- Port Adelaide:
GOALS - Port Adelaide: Hansen, Oliver 2; Callinan, Mack WAFL: Morgans 2; McKenzie, Orr, Rogers, Waugh
ATTENDANCE: 6,000 approximately at Fremantle Oval
[Home]
[Great Games]
1. Melbourne and Norwood visited Tasmania; Geelong, North Adelaide and Fitzroy went to Sydney; Sturt travelled to Ballarat; Collingwood visited Adelaide; and South Fremantle and East Fremantle both journeyed to Kalgoorlie and Boulder. Far and away the most extensive travel, however, was undertaken by Port Adelaide, which ventured to Broken Hill, the West Australian goldfields, and Perth. Details of the matches engaged in by all these clubs can be found in the Extracurricular Matches and Championship of Australia sections. Return to Main Text
2.
